The Best First Year Player trophy was awarded only sporadically prior to 1960. When it first appeared as a regular trophy, in 1960, it was called the Collingwood Rotary Club Trophy. In 1988 the name was changed to the Harry Collier Trophy. Collier played 18 matches in his first season in 1926 and kicked 32 goals.  His ability to hit the scoreboard was clear from early on with the 18-year-old held goalless in just four matches in his debut season. Collier went on to become a six-time premiership player – 1927, 1928, 1929, 1930, 1935 and 1936. Upon retirement he became a popular commentator in television’s early years in Melbourne from 1956. Collier’s career was one of the greatest of any at Victoria Park as he won two best and fairests (1928 and 1930) and was captain from 1935-9.

Year Harry Collier Trophy winner
1927 Harry Rumney
1928 Bruce Andrew
1929 George Gibbs
1935 Bervin Woods
1936 Ron Dowling
1937 Des Fothergill
1960 Peter Rosenbrock
1961 John Mahon
1962 Mick Bone
1963 Terry Waters
1964 Paul Wadham
1965 Colin Tully
1966 Wayne Richardson
1967 Ross Dunne
1968 Denis O'Callaghan
1969 Max Richardson
1970 Peter Eakins
1971 Mike Delahunty
1972 Rod Oborne
1973 Paul Cranage
1974 Ray Shaw
1975 Andrew Ireland
1976 Chris Perry
1977 Ricky Barham
1978 Craig Stewart
1979 Denis Banks
1980 Terry Domburg
1981 Noel Lovell
1982 Chris Dalkin
1983 Phillip Walsh
1984 Darren Millane
1985 Gordon Sumner
1986 Dannie Seow
1987 Craig Starcevich
1988 Graham Wright
1989 Colin Alexander
1990 Tony Francis/ Scott Russell
1991 Paul Williams
1992 Mark Fraser
1993 Kent Butcher
1994 Jon Hassall
1995 Scott Burns
1996 Simon Prestigiacomo
1997 Mal Michael
1998 Clinton King
1999 Rupert Betheras
2000 Josh Fraser
2001 Ryan Lonie
2002 Jason Cloke
2003 Matthew Lokan
2004 Guy Richards
2005 Travis Cloke
2006 Dale Thomas
2007 Tyson Goldsack
2008 Nathan Brown
2009 Dayne Beams
2010 Jarryd Blair
2011 Alex Fasolo
2012 Jamie Elliott
2013 Josh Thomas
2014 Tom Langdon
2015 Jordan De Goey
2016 Josh Smith
2017 Callum Brown
2018 Jaidyn Stephenson
2019 John Noble
2020 Isaac Quaynor
2021 Oliver Henry
2022 Nick Daicos
2023 Jakob Ryan
2024 Joe Richards