Third Best and Fairest (J.J. Joyce Trophy)
- Darcy Cameron2026
- Isaac Quaynor2025
- Josh Daicos2024
- Darcy Moore2022
- Scott Pendlebury2021, 2018, 2008
- Jack Crisp2020, 2019, 2015
- Adam Treloar2017
- Steele Sidebottom2016, 2013
- Dayne Beams2014
- Dane Swan2012
- Travis Cloke2011
- Dale Thomas2010
- Heath Shaw2009
- Tarkyn Lockyer2007
- Shane Wakelin2005
- Scott Burns2003
- James Clement2002
- Nathan Buckley2001
- Paul Williams2000, 1997, 1996
- Simon Prestigiacomo2000
- Gavin Brown1999, 1988
- Stephen Patterson1998
- Scott Russell1996, 1992, 1991, 1990
- Gavin Crosisca1995, 1989
- Damian Monkhorst1994, 1993, 1992
- Graham Wright1990
- Darren Millane1988, 1986
- Jamie Turner1987
- Greg Phillips1985
- David Cloke1984
- Phillip Walsh1983
- Craig Stewart1982, 1980
- Tony Shaw1981
- Stan Magro1979, 1978
- Peter Moore1977
- Ron Wearmouth1976
- Bill Picken1975
- John Williams1974
- Robert Dean1973
- John Greening1972, 1970
- Peter McKenna1971, 1968
- Terry Waters1969, 1963
- Ernie Hug1967
- Len Thompson1966
- Ken Turner1965, 1961
- Ray Gabelich1964
- John Henderson1962
- Brian Gray1960
- Bill Serong1959
- Harry Sullivan1958
- Frank Tuck1957
- Mick Twomey1956
- Neil Mann1955
- Lerrel Sharp1954
- Des Healey1953
- Thorold Merrett1952
- Lou Richards1951, 1946
- George Hams1950
- Charlie Utting1949
- Bill Twomey Jnr1948
- Gordon Hocking1947
- Herb Naismith1942
- Alby Pannam1941
- R. Jack Ross1940
- Ron Todd1939, 1938
- Marcus Whelan1937
- Phonse Kyne1936
- Vin Doherty1935
- Gordon Coventry1934
- Len Murphy1934
- Fred Froude1933
- Billy Libbis1927