Collingwood has been associated with great goalkickers from its very first years. Indeed, Collingwood players won the VFL/AFL goalkicking title 22 times in the competition's first 43 seasons. Even among so many great sharpshooters, one man stands above the rest: Gordon Coventry was the first man to ever kick 100 in a season, and his eventual career tally of 1299 goals stood for more than 60 years. Today, the Gordon Coventry Award is presented to Collingwood's leading goalkicker for the season.

Year Leading Goalkicker
1892 George Anderson/ Archie Smith 12
1893 George Anderson 20
1894 Archie Smith 25
1895 Archie Smith 27
1896 Wal Gillard 13
1897 Archie Smith 15
1898 Archie Smith 31
1899 Archie Smith 17
1900 Archie Smith 21
1901 Ted Rowell 31
1902 Ted Rowell 33
1903 Ted Lockwood 35
1904 Charlie H. Pannam 24
1905 Charlie H. Pannam 38
1906 Dick Lee 35
1907 Dick Lee 47
1908 Dick Lee 54
1909 Dick Lee 58
1910 Dick Lee 58
1911 Tom Baxter 31
1912 Les Hughes 13
1913 Les Hughes 22
1914 Dick Lee 57
1915 Dick Lee 66
1916 Dick Lee 48
1917 Dick Lee 54
1918 Tom Wraith 26
1919 Dick Lee 56
1920 Ern Utting 23
1921 Dick Lee 64
1922 Gordon Coventry 42
1923 Gordon Coventry 36
1924 Gordon Coventry 28
1925 Gordon Coventry 68
1926 Gordon Coventry 83
1927 Gordon Coventry 97
1928 Gordon Coventry 89
1929 Gordon Coventry 124
1930 Gordon Coventry 118
1931 Gordon Coventry 67
1932 Gordon Coventry 82
1933 Gordon Coventry 108
1934 Gordon Coventry 105
1935 Gordon Coventry 88
1936 Gordon Coventry 60
1937 Gordon Coventry 72
1938 Ron Todd 120
1939 Ron Todd 121
1940 Des Fothergill 56
1941 Albie Pannam 42
1942 Albie Pannam 37
1943 Albie Pannam 40
1944 Lou Richards/ Bob Galbally 26
1945 Des Fothergill 62
1946 Des Fothergill 63
1947 Neil Mann 48
1948 Lou Richards 44
1949 Jack Pimm 34
1950 Lou Richards 35
1951 Maurie Dunstan 40
1952 Maurie Dunstan 43
1953 Bob Rose 36
1954 Keith Bromage 22
1955 Ken Smale 47
1956 Ken Smale 33
1957 Ian Brewer 26
1958 Ian Brewer 73
1959 Murray Weideman 36
1960 Murray Weideman 30
1961 Kevin Pay 31
1962 Murray Weideman 48
1963 Terry Waters 50
1964 Ian Graham 42
1965 David Norman 32
1966 Ian Graham 58
1967 Peter McKenna 47
1968 Peter McKenna 64
1969 Peter McKenna 98
1970 Peter McKenna 143
1971 Peter McKenna 134
1972 Peter McKenna 130
1973 Peter McKenna 86
1974 Peter McKenna 69
1975 Phil Carman 41
1976 Phil Carman 38
1977 Peter Moore 76
1978 Peter Moore 57
1979 Craig Davis 88
1980 Craig Davis 52
1981 Peter Daicos 76
1982 Peter Daicos 58
1983 Michael Richardson 49
1984 Mark Williams 53
1985 Brian Taylor 80
1986 Brian Taylor 100
1987 Brian Taylor 60
1988 Brian Taylor 73
1989 Brian Taylor 49
1990 Peter Daicos 97
1991 Peter Daicos 75
1992 Peter Daicos 52
1993 Saverio Rocca 73
1994 Saverio Rocca 49
1995 Saverio Rocca 93
1996 Saverio Rocca 66
1997 Saverio Rocca 76
1998 Saverio Rocca 68
1999 Saverio Rocca 33
2000 Anthony Rocca 33
2001 Chris Tarrant 53
2002 Chris Tarrant/Anthony Rocca 38
2003 Chris Tarrant 54
2004 Chris Tarrant 36
2005 Chris Tarrant 36
2006 Anthony Rocca 55
2007 Anthony Rocca 54
2008 Paul Medhurst 50
2009 John Anthony 50
2010 Alan Didak 41
2011 Travis Cloke 69
2012 Travis Cloke 59
2013 Travis Cloke 68
2014 Travis Cloke 39
2015 Jamie Elliott 35
2016 Alex Fasolo 25
2017 Jamie Elliott 34
2018 Jordan De Goey 48
2019 Brody Mihocek 36
2020 Brody Mihocek 25
2021 Brody Mihocek 34
2022 Brody Mihocek 41
2023 Brody Mihocek 47
2024 Bobby Hill 30