Runner up Best and Fairest (R.T. Rush Trophy)
- Josh Daicos2026
- Nick Daicos2025, 2023
- Darcy Cameron2024
- Brayden Maynard2023, 2021
- Scott Pendlebury2022, 2020, 2019, 2012, 2010, 2007
- Taylor Adams2017
- Adam Treloar2016
- Dane Swan2015, 2013, 2011
- Steele Sidebottom2014
- Nick Maxwell2009
- Paul Medhurst2008
- Ben Johnson2006, 2004
- James Clement2006
- Brodie Holland2005
- Paul Licuria2004
- Shane Woewodin2004
- Chris Tarrant2003
- Scott Burns2002, 1996
- Jarrod Molloy2001
- Tarkyn Lockyer2000
- Anthony Rocca1999
- Gavin Crosisca1998
- Nathan Buckley1997
- Paul Williams1995
- Shane Watson1993
- Gary Pert1992
- Gavin Brown1991
- Darren Millane1990
- Paul Hawke1989
- Mick McGuane1988
- Shane Morwood1988, 1985
- Matt Ryan1987
- Bruce Abernethy1986
- Denis Banks1984
- Michael Taylor1983, 1982
- Bill Picken1981, 1979, 1977
- Ray Byrne1980
- Len Thompson1976, 1969
- Robert Hyde1975
- Max Richardson1974
- Wayne Richardson1973, 1968, 1967
- Peter McKenna1972
- Des Tuddenham1971, 1966, 1965
- Graeme Jenkin1970
- John Henderson1964, 1961
- Warren Roper1963
- Brian Gray1962
- Bill Serong1960
- Ray Gabelich1959
- Ken Turner1958
- Ron Kingston1957
- Bill Jones1956
- Peter Lucas1955, 1952
- Des Healey1954, 1951
- Neil Mann1953, 1948
- Lou Richards1950, 1947
- Phonse Kyne1949, 1939, 1938
- Bill Twomey Jnr1946
- Norm Campbell1942
- Jack Regan1941, 1937, 1934
- Marcus Whelan1940, 1936
- Len Murphy1935
- Jack Beveridge1933