This award was first presented as a one-off in 1978, to acknowledge Ronnie Wearmouth’s gutsy performance in that year’s preliminary final.

It was reintroduced several years later, and re-named the Jock McHale Trophy.

The list of winners reflects some of the bravest players to ever pull on a Collingwood jumper, with Tony Shaw and Gavin Brown each winning it four times.

The award ended in 1999, and the Jock McHale Trophy became attached to the player finishing fourth in the best and fairest count.

Year Most Courageous Player
1978 Ron Wearmouth
1982 Mark Williams
1983 Tony Shaw
1984 Denis Banks
1985 Mark Williams
1986 Denis Banks
1987 Jamie Turner
1988 Gavin Brown
1989 Tony Shaw
1990 Darren Millane
1991 Gavin Brown
1992 Gavin Brown
1993 Tony Shaw
1994 Tony Shaw
1995 Jason Wild
1996 Jason Wild
1997 Jason Wild
1998 Andrew Schauble
1999 Gavin Brown