Our records for the reserves are incomplete, especially for the period when Collingwood Districts acted as our reserves team, and also for the years between 1939 and 1957. Those years marked with an asterisk are years where we are not yet 100% certain of the leading goalkicker for that season. Until we get extra information we have included the name of the player with the most goals based on the details we have so far. There are some other years where we are sure of the identity of the winner, but some doubt exists over his final tally. We have marked those with two asterisks. We are confident of the details from 1958 onwards, as these entries have been compiled using Collingwood, VFL and AFL data. If you have ANY information about the reserves team/results/scores that you think might help us fill in some of the gaps please contact us at [email protected]

Year Leading Goalkicker
1919 Ern Utting 91 (as Collingwood Districts)
1920 Herbie Taylor 24*
1921 Ern Utting 24*
1922 George Clayden 12*
1923 George Clayden 36
1924 Cliff Monohan 23*
1925 Albert Collier 23*
1926 Tommy Bird 16*
1927 Bill Fitzgerald 10*
1928 Bill Fitzgerald 26*
1929 TBA
1930 Fred Froude 38*
1931 Dan Peterson 15*
1932 Dan Peterson 22*
1933 Phonse Kyne 23*
1934 Lou Riley, Jim Toone 18*
1935 Ron Todd 41**
1936 Des Fothergill 43**
1937 Lou Riley 30*
1938 Stan Dawson 40**
1939 Len Hustler 21* (as Collingwood Reserves)
1940 Lou Richards 38*
1941 Len Hustler 19*
1942 No team entered
1943 Jack Arnott 51
1944 TBA
1945 TBA
1946 TBA
1947 TBA
1948 TBA
1949 TBA
1950 Jack Finck 21*
1951 Jack Finck 33
1952 Barry Taylor 29
1953 Keith Bromage 35
1954 Kevin Wylie 15*
1955 Kevin Wylie 26
1956 Keith Bromage 22
1957 Tony Heath 20
1958 Keith Burns 27
1959 Merv Hicks 35
1960 Ian Abraham 23
1961 Barry Perry 24
1962 Peter Marshall 38 (VFL winner)
1963 Ian Graham 36 (VFL winner)
1964 Mick Erwin 29
1965 Max Ballantyne 32
1966 Peter McKenna 46 (VFL winner)
1967 Ross Dunne 50
1968 Robert Stevens 25
1969 Gordon Lawrie 33
1970 Gordon Lawrie 41
1971 John Jordan 39
1972 Graeme Dunstan 29
1973 Robert Bird 24
1974 Shane Bond 28
1975 Greg Beck 30
1976 Peter McCormack 50
1977 Terry Philippe 74
1978 Ted Carroll 32
1979 David Twomey 63
1980 Wes Fellowes 66
1981 Glenn Bellinger 38
1982 Tony Russell 45
1983 Tony Russell 52
1984 Dale Woodhall 57
1985 Dannie Seow 27
1986 Darren Collins 44
1987 John Mrakov 34
1988 Ron McKeown 35
1989 Mark Bayliss 37
1990 Brian Taylor 51
1991 Mark Richardson 52
1992 Brad Hardie 47
1993 Ron McKeown 56
1994 Aaron James 37
1995 Chad Liddell 24
1996 Ben Wilson 65
1997 Aaron James, Brad Fuller 28
1998 Andrew Pugsley 24
1999 Matthew Manfield 28
2000 Brad Oborne 19 (as Collingwood in the VFL)
2008 Brent MacAffer 38
2009 Chris Bryan 35
2010 Scott Reed 27
2011 Brett Eddy 21
2012 Jackson Paine, Caolan Mooney 17
2013 Jackson Paine 45
2014 Patrick Karnezis 31
2015 Patrick Karnezis 30
2016 Travis Cloke, Jordan Collopy 18
2017  Kayle Kirby 43
2018 Andrew Gallucci 25
2019 Andrew Gallucci 18
2020 N/A
2021 Jack Ginnivan 16
2022 Sam Fowler 25
2023 Reef McInnes 32
2024 Ash Johnson 21