There was no runner-up best and fairest named in the first half-dozen years of the Copeland Trophy. In 1933, however, the club began to acknowledge those players who finished second and third, by awarding each of them a trophy named after Cecil Hearne. From 1941 onwards, the award for runner-up best and fairest has carried the name of dual Premiership player and long-serving club Treasurer Bob Rush. His greatest acknowledgment was arguably his induction into the Order of the British Empire for his services to football in 1961, the only Collingwood player to ever be honoured in that manner.  

Year R.T. Rush Trophy winner
1933 Jack Beveridge
1934 Jack Regan
1935 Len Murphy
1936 Marcus Whelan
1937 Jack Regan
1938 Phonse Kyne
1939 Phonse Kyne
1940 Marcus Whelan
1941 Jack Regan
1942 Norm Campbell
1943 No award – WW2
1944 No award – WW2
1945 No award – WW2
1946 Bill Twomey Jnr
1947 Lou Richards
1948 Neil Mann
1949 Phonse Kyne
1950 Lou Richards
1951 Des Healey
1952 Peter Lucas
1953 Neil Mann
1954 Des Healey
1955 Peter Lucas
1956 Bill Jones
1957 Ron Kingston
1958 Ken Turner
1959 Ray Gabelich 
1960 Bill Serong
1961 John Henderson
1962 Brian Gray
1963 Warren Roper
1964 John Henderson
1965 Des Tuddenham
1966 Des Tuddenham
1967 Wayne Richardson
1968 Wayne Richardson
1969 Len Thompson
1970 Graeme Jenkin
1971 Des Tuddenham
1972 Peter McKenna
1973 Wayne Richardson
1974 Max Richardson
1975 Robert Hyde
1976 Len Thompson
1977 Bill Picken
1978 Not awarded (tie for Copeland)
1979 Bill Picken
1980 Ray Byrne
1981 Bill Picken
1982 Michael Taylor
1983 Michael Taylor
1984 Denis Banks
1985 Shane Morwood
1986 Bruce Abernethy
1987 Matthew Ryan
1988 Mick McGuane/ Shane Morwood
1989 Paul Hawke
1990 Darren Millane
1991 Gavin Brown
1992 Gary Pert
1993 Shane Watson
1994 Not awarded (tie for Copeland)
1995 Paul Williams
1996 Scott Burns
1997 Nathan Buckley
1998 Gavin Crosisca
1999 Anthony Rocca
2000 Tarkyn Lockyer
2001 Jarrod Molloy
2002 Scott Burns
2003 Chris Tarrant
2004 Ben Johnson/ Paul Licuria/ Shane Woewodin
2005 Brodie Holland
2006 James Clement/ Ben Johnson
2007 Scott Pendlebury
2008 Paul Medhurst
2009 Nick Maxwell
2010 Scott Pendlebury
2011 Dane Swan
2012 Scott Pendlebury
2013 Dane Swan
2014 Steele Sidebottom
2015 Dane Swan
2016 Adam Treloar
2017 Taylor Adams
2018 None (tie for first)
2019 Scott Pendlebury
2020 Scott Pendlebury
2021 Brayden Maynard
2022 Scott Pendlebury
2023 Nick Daicos/ Brayden Maynard
2024 Darcy Cameron